Menu
Pro Login/Register
Shop

Quiver Killer SUP Surf Test 2023 / SUPBOARDER PRO HEAD TO HEAD

In this SUPboarder PRO head to head test we put 11 surf iSUPs priced between £400 and £1400 up against each other. Surf iSUPs have been on the market for afew years now, and in 2022 there are definitely more than 2 to choose from! Whether you're looking for a compact surf SUP to take on holiday with you or leave in the back of your car, or for easier storage at home, the range of surf iSUPs now available has something for everyone. Heavier riders will most likely be looking for more stable boards with more glide. And lighter riders will be looking for boards with less weight and thickness. Our head to head comparison will help you decide which board is right for YOU!

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

51 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
jeroensurf@gmail.com
jeroensurf@gmail.com
7 months ago

Great test!
Question, you guys tested the Hipster with the pintail.
In the past Reuben tested the Hipster with the swallowtail.
Can you say something about how they compare/where they differ in feel/performance?

I have the swallowtail model in 8.3, but struggeled a bit with it in really fast hollow waves, so paired it with an Spitfire8.6 but if this could do both….

Salmonpincher
7 months ago

A fascinating review as always. Its been a long summer waiting for decent waves (& reviews) I’m interested in a quiver killer to fit between my 113l jp surf & 139l infinity new deal (or maybe replace both). I’m 85kg without UK wetsuits & think my sweetspot for performance & all day riding comfort is around 125l. Both my boards are 29″ wide & I don’t like the idea of being 30″+ for width for that sort of volume – which puts me off going for another board (which maybe I won’t like / or really need). I have had… Read more »

Salmonpincher
7 months ago
Reply to  Beau Nixon

Thanks beau. I like both the idea of the starboard pro & the smik custom too – I’ll have a look at the others too

Salmonpincher
2 months ago
Reply to  Beau Nixon

After much deliberation I’m going for the 8’10 JP surf. I have the 8’6 & love it, but I’ve just holidayed Barbados & rented the 8’10 & surfed several spots (up to double overhead) & it’s given me the performance, stability & dimensions I’m looking for

DAVIDE MESSINEO
DAVIDE MESSINEO
7 months ago

Great test!
Question, you guys tested the Hipster with the pintail. I’m 80kg intermediate rider and usually ride my Quatro Carve pro 8.2 120lt that feels perfect on big ocean waves during my holiday but is difficult to paddle in Italian choppy waves, so unstable for that volume.
I’ve been wanting to go down in volume for a long time but changing the board for a more forgiving one. Looking at your test I ‘m sure that the Hipster Pin 7.10 would be perfect. What do you think?

Dave B
Dave B
7 months ago

I have the 7.10 hipster pin, it’s marginally more unstable than an infinity blurr v2 at 8.2, at the same width and volume, due to it being shorter. Both are manageable for me at 58 yo 83 kg, even in quite choppy conditions. Tend to ise thr V2 in bigger waves, but it takes time to adjust between the two boards, as I mainly ride the hipster.

Nigel
Nigel
7 months ago

I’m 80-85kg and recently got an 8.0 Hipster Twin because I wanted something stable but agile in all conditions. It’s a great board and feels surprisingly small and agile for its size. I would reccomend it.

Troy Cleary
7 months ago

Great review. Definitely a tight choice between the splice and hipster. The pin tail on the smik is a great improvement. Personally I ride my 8”8 and 9”3 splice as twin fins with a small Center fin ( smik hipster inspired lol ) and this really brings the splice to life. Both amazing boards, I do find the hipster a little faster and better down the line. Both are light years ahead of the crowd in my opinion. I have a custom 9”0 x 31 hipster twin pin coming to compare to my already 8”10 x32 and 9”2 x32 hipsters.

Reuben Ellis
Admin
7 months ago
Reply to  Troy Cleary

Great Comment Troy. Need to try the Spice as a twiny!

Dave
Dave
7 months ago
Reply to  Troy Cleary

I set my 8.4 Sunova flow 2 up as a Twin, and it transformed its performance. I think in general most SUP of this genre, bit wider, less rocker, work well with twin fins, due to their wide positioning, giving them a good pivot point, making the board a lot looser etc.

Fabrizio Ferzetti
7 months ago

Congratulations for the excellent choice of products and test approach. Since I don’t understand English very well or quickly, it would be really convenient to be able to read the transcript of the test on the web page. I really appreciated the test because it concerns the search for my new quiver for an all-round board especially on Italian breaks. I am an intermediate surfer 1.75 m tall and 65 kg in weight who currently uses a Gong Zero FSP PRO 9×29.5 115 liters which I use in situations with rougher or coarser seas and a Gong MOB FSP PRO… Read more »

Reuben Ellis
Admin
7 months ago

Hey Fabrizio , Thanks for your comment. I will send it to Beau so he can get back to you. We are going to put subtitles over the video also. So I hope this helps. Thanks for the subscription.

Fabrizio Ferzetti
7 months ago
Reply to  Reuben Ellis

Thank you for reply…

Christina Doviak
Christina Doviak
7 months ago

Really enjoyed this, good to see how the different tail shapes and thicknesses affected the wave riding. How did Lucy get along with the boards? I’m guessing she’s a lighter weight rider so would be curious if these were all over volumed and a bit sluggish.
At 60-ish kg I think I have always over volumed myself just because of what was available on the market and my turns have suffered from it. Any chance of having a similar review session for lighter weight/female riders?

Lucy Ellis
Admin
7 months ago

Hi Christina. I’m 67kg and yes like you often find myself riding boards with too much volume, which then feel slow and hard to manouever on the wave. The Smik however, despite being similar in volume to the other boards in test felt so much more enjoyable to ride, even for a rider of my weight.Lively and easy to turn on the wave, and yet still plenty of stability. Definitely my favourite on test by far. We will certainly try our best to ensure lighter riders are more included in future tests. If you have any questions about specific boards… Read more »

Steve Williams
Steve Williams
7 months ago

The template of the Spice and SMIK are pretty identical ….but that’s not to say the rocker, hull features etc are the same. One board that would have been interesting to have tested is one of the smaller Jimmy Lewis Destroyers.

Reuben Ellis
Admin
7 months ago
Reply to  Steve Williams

Hey Steve, We did almost get a Jimmy Lewis in the test, but it didn’t make it unfortunately. It sounds like a lot of readers are riding their Spice’s with a hipter fin set up and loving it.

cam
cam
7 months ago

love the intro music

Reuben Ellis
Admin
7 months ago
Reply to  cam

Nice

Phast
Phast
6 months ago

Fantastic test! Thank you so much to the three of you!!! I’m happy that both, the Spice and the Placid made it to the top three! I WISH the SMIK would be available in the U.S.. Do you happen to have some information how / where I could get a Hipster Twin in the U.S.? Also, I wonder how the GenRation SP25 would have scored in the test instead of the Sunova Placid, as well as Rick Weeks’ newest creation, the Sunova “Ghost” (which hasn’t been released yet). In case I would not be able to get the SMIK Hipster… Read more »

Russell Davidson
Russell Davidson
6 months ago

Great test. After advice from Beau earlier this year I got a SMIK Hipster twin and absolutely love it. Was torn between it and the Spice, but after talking to Beau decided Hipster better for my style of riding. It is awesome. I know your equipment is not meant to make you a better rider, but feel like my backside riding has gone to a new level with the Hipster. Awesome bit of kit. Cheers guys!

Reuben Ellis
Admin
6 months ago

Nice one Russell.

Kurt B.
Kurt B.
6 months ago

Hello Beau/ Reuben, You guys did an awesome job with the quiver killer review, in fact, I joined the SupboarderPro site, just for the review and I appreciate the info as I’m in the market for a board as we speak and I am trending towards the Hipster Twin Pin; which looks amazing. A couple quick questions, I didn’t see a mention of you or Reubens body dimensions (Height and weight, with or without wetsuit)?, which would help in this process. What was your thought on your ability to stand up for a session without the need to go prone… Read more »

Reuben Ellis
Admin
6 months ago
Reply to  Kurt B.

Hi Kurt. Thanks for your comment I’m glad you found the test useful. Yes we do need to add our weights onto the post and in the future we should definitely add this information into the video as well. I also think talking about what the boards I like to stand on on flat water and the general stability of the boards with maybe a few extra shots would be beneficial as well. Thanks so much for the input on this. For me I weigh 75 kg maybe 76 with a wet wet suit and I didn’t have a problem… Read more »

Kurt Birchler
Kurt Birchler
6 months ago
Reply to  Beau Nixon

Beau & Reuben, I can’t thank you and Reuben enough for the quick response and input, it’s greatly appreciated. In my opinion, both you and Reuben have excellent points regarding all of the boards and no doubt, everyone appreciates your impartiality for each of the manufacturers presented. When I watch your videos, I can visualize what my experience would be like on the same board (obviously I am not at your level of expertise), however, I can look at all of the other factors involved in the ride of that board i.e. Paddling, float, wave entry etc.. The reason why your reviews have… Read more »

Reuben Ellis
Admin
6 months ago
Reply to  Kurt Birchler

Hey Kurt. No worries at all. I’m super glad you found the video and post helpful. We do both personally really enjoy making sure people get on the right equipment for them. And obviously love trying all the boards as well :-). Can’t wait to hear your feedback of your board when it arrives. I’m sure you’ll enjoy ripping with it as much as we have been. Thanks again for the comment it’s always great to hear.

Levon Scheijbeler
5 months ago

Awesome test and pretty good conditions to test them as well! I was a bit later to see the video but never the less I saw it. Also cool that I guessed the outcome correctly back in June on the introduction of the “quiver killer” and good that you made the definition clear of the quiver killer. Like Jeroen, Cheers from the Netherlands!

Reuben Ellis
Admin
5 months ago

Glad you like the test and good to hear you guessed the results ;-). Happy SUPing

Johan Maritz
Johan Maritz
3 months ago

Hi Guys
Thanks for this interesting test.
I am 70kg and went from a 8×30 115L Jimmy Lewis Superfrank ( fantastic board up to head high btw) to a 7’11” 98L Infinity RNB.
I can’t comment on Smik etc but as an intermediate surfer in US east coast beach break that’s often choppy, I love the RNB and would recommend it to any early intermediate and beyond surfer. Maybe your views on it would have been different if you’d used one size smaller. Cheers

Rob Shaul
Rob Shaul
3 months ago

Hi Beau –

I’m currently on a 2023 8’2″ All Wave and looking to for the next progression. Should the Spice be a consideration, or is it too similar to the All Wave? Thanks! – R

cam
cam
3 months ago

Hi. I hope i am not too off topic but have you guys ever ridden the Starboard Hero 9.0. I have seen a few come up in the used market and as a beginer 180 pound sup person. It looks like it could be fun. Fairly lite and relatively decent in flat water and looks really good in the surf. Any thoughts ? Thanks

Reuben Ellis
Admin
3 months ago
Reply to  cam

Hey Cam , Yes I have its very similar to the older Whooper also. It was a great fun board to use in the smaller surf and on flatwater. This boards are well worth looking at. Pretty easy to buy and sell too!

cam
cam
3 months ago
Reply to  Reuben Ellis

I found one cheap but hummed and hawed too long and it sold quickly.It had a hole intentionally placed on the bow. I think that the version with the hole had a slower layup. . It would be easy to lockup though

Reuben Ellis
Admin
3 months ago
Reply to  cam

The one that go away… Keep an eye out for the Whoopers as well! Yeah these boards are easy to fix really.

cam
cam
3 months ago
Reply to  Reuben Ellis

Reuben have you tried both the Whopper 10 and 9.4 ? If so which one did you prefer ?

Reuben Ellis
Admin
3 months ago
Reply to  cam

The last Whopper I used was the the one in the video https://supboardermag.com/2019/04/19/wide-surf-shapes-from-starboard-compared-whopper-wide-point-and-hyper-nut/ the 10, But I know I would prefer the 9’4 because I weight 75kg and I would need the extra width.

cam
cam
3 months ago
Reply to  Reuben Ellis

Thanks Reuben. I just watched the video. I am surprised that with your experience you would prefer 33 wide over 32 wide. I lost 20 pounds so I am getting closer to your weight.

Reuben Ellis
Admin
3 months ago
Reply to  cam

That is true a narrow board is usually more fun. But the Whooper is a super fun board.

Berrie
Berrie
22 days ago

I loved the review, thank you very much.!
Good information to choose my new board. I thought I was there until I found brand “Allwater” which I never heard of.

https://allwateradvantage.com/range/

Especially the New Beauty.

Do you have any experience on this boards?

The outline looks normal, but the bottom shape is new to me. Is it possible that it’s good as the claim it be?

I’m 56, had a lot of back surgery. So a need stability ans I also like performance ans speed.

Reuben Ellis
Admin
21 days ago
Reply to  Berrie

Hey Berrie, We have not heard of that brand ,but having a look, they do look good. Nice shapes.
This board could defo be a great quiver killer.
What width of board are you thinking?
Any chance you could demo one?

Berrie
Berrie
20 days ago
Reply to  Reuben Ellis

Hi Reuben, Thank you for your response. I would consider the 31.5 ” ( l believe 128l) or even ask for i little bit bigger. (Between 130 and 135 liter). The problem is there is no demo in Europe. So i would just have to take the risk for a considerable amount of money. I’m afraid that’s to big of a gamble for me. That’s a shame because somehow I have a feeling this board would fit me. Maybe you guys can test it for me? There a few sold in Europe, maybe one of the owners is reading this,… Read more »

Reuben Ellis
Admin
18 days ago
Reply to  Berrie

Yeah be great to know how they ride. We will try and get one. It could be worth a gamble tho!

Related brand posts

Related posts

QR: Quiver Killer SUP Surf Test 2023 / SUPBOARDER PRO HEAD TO HEAD

Brand Partners

51
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x